Why This Comparison Exists Right Now
You received notice from Texas DPS that you need SR-22 filing to reinstate your license, and you're comparing Dairyland and The General because both specialize in high-risk auto insurance and both appear on every SR-22 carrier list for Texas. You've probably seen contradictory rate estimates across different quote tools, and you're trying to figure out which carrier files faster and costs less for your specific situation.
The structural reality: Dairyland and The General operate through different underwriting entities in Texas, and those entities create county-level variation in filing speed and premium calculation that neither carrier's marketing surfaces. This article walks the actual filing mechanics, the rate differences that matter, and the non-owner policy distinctions that apply when you don't currently own a vehicle.
Compare car insurance rates in your state
Get quotes from licensed carriers — no obligation, no spam, results in minutes.
Get Your Free QuoteTexas Underwriter Names
Security National vs Old American
Dairyland policies in Texas are underwritten by Security National Insurance Company (NAIC 33120). The General policies are underwritten by Old American County Mutual Fire Insurance Company. These are the actual entities filing your SR-22 with DPS, and they process filings on different timelines depending on county workload.
Texas Department of Insurance licensure records
What SR-22 Filing Actually Requires in Texas
Texas requires SR-22 for DWI convictions, Administrative License Revocation (ALR) suspensions, uninsured driving citations, and certain repeat traffic violations. The filing itself is a certificate of financial responsibility your carrier submits electronically to the Texas Department of Public Safety. DPS requires continuous coverage for 2 years from your reinstatement date under Texas Transportation Code §601.153.
Both Dairyland and The General file SR-22 electronically through the state's TexasSure system. Filing speed depends on the underwriter's processing queue and county-specific DPS verification lag, not the brand name on the quote. When you buy a policy, the carrier transmits the SR-22 to DPS within 1 business day in most counties, but DPS confirmation back to you can take 3-5 business days depending on current backlog.
The $100 reinstatement fee DPS charges is separate from the SR-22 filing fee your carrier charges. Dairyland typically charges $15-$25 for SR-22 filing; The General charges $20-$30. Neither fee is negotiable, and both are one-time charges at policy inception. If your policy lapses during the 2-year SR-22 period, DPS receives an automatic cancellation notice and re-suspends your license within 10 days.
The carrier filing your SR-22 must maintain continuous coverage for 24 months. A single lapse triggers automatic re-suspension, and DPS does not send advance warning before the suspension takes effect.
Premium Comparison: Dairyland vs The General
Dairyland rates SR-22 policies using a tiered non-standard pricing model that treats DWI, reckless driving, and uninsured violations as separate risk buckets. Texas DWI filers typically see monthly premiums between $110 and $190 depending on county, age, and whether you need liability-only or full coverage. Uninsured driving citations produce lower premiums, typically $85-$140 per month for minimum liability coverage. Dairyland offers a discount for drivers who complete DWI education programs voluntarily before reinstatement, which can reduce premiums by 8-12% in the first policy year.
The General uses a flat high-risk pricing model with less variation by violation type. Texas DWI filers pay approximately $105-$180 per month for liability coverage, and uninsured filers pay $90-$150. The General does not offer violation-specific discounts, but they accept payment plans with lower down payments than Dairyland requires — typically 15% of the six-month premium upfront versus Dairyland's 20-25%. For a driver paying $120/month, that translates to a $108 down payment at The General versus $144-$180 at Dairyland.
Related Articles
Non-Owner SR-22 Policies When You Don't Own a Vehicle
If you don't currently own a vehicle but need SR-22 to reinstate your Texas license, both carriers offer non-owner policies. A non-owner policy provides liability coverage when you drive a vehicle you do not own — borrowed cars, rental cars, or employer-provided vehicles. It does not cover a vehicle titled in your name, and it does not cover regular access to a household vehicle registered to someone else.
Dairyland non-owner SR-22 premiums in Texas typically range from $40 to $75 per month for state minimum liability ($30,000 bodily injury per person, $60,000 per accident, $25,000 property damage). The General's non-owner SR-22 premiums range from $45 to $80 per month for the same coverage limits. Both carriers require continuous monthly payment — if you miss a payment, the policy cancels and DPS receives the lapse notice immediately.
The critical distinction: Dairyland allows you to convert a non-owner policy to a standard owner policy mid-term if you buy a vehicle during the SR-22 period. The General requires you to cancel the non-owner policy and buy a new owner policy, which restarts your SR-22 filing clock. If you're 18 months into your 2-year SR-22 requirement and you buy a car, Dairyland preserves your progress; The General resets you to month zero.
County Filing Speed Gap
1-3 business days
Security National (Dairyland's Texas underwriter) processes SR-22 filings in Harris, Dallas, Tarrant, and Bexar counties within 1 business day on average. Old American County Mutual (The General's underwriter) processes filings in those same counties within 2-3 business days. Rural counties show less variation because both underwriters batch-process lower-volume areas weekly.
Texas DPS TexasSure system processing records
Filing Speed and Reinstatement Timeline
The faster your carrier files SR-22 with DPS, the sooner you can pay your reinstatement fee and schedule your license reissue appointment. Dairyland's underwriter, Security National, transmits filings to TexasSure within 24 hours of policy binding in urban counties. DPS confirmation typically appears in your online driver record within 3-4 business days after transmission. The General's underwriter, Old American County Mutual, transmits filings within 48-72 hours of binding, and DPS confirmation appears 4-6 business days after that.
If you're operating under an Occupational Driver License (ODL) and approaching the end of your suspension period, this 1-3 day difference matters. Texas law requires SR-22 filing to be active in the DPS system before you can pay the reinstatement fee, and the reinstatement fee must clear before you can apply for full license restoration. A 3-day filing delay pushes your entire reinstatement timeline back by nearly a week when you factor in DPS processing and appointment availability.
Which Carrier to Choose Based on Your Situation
Choose Dairyland if you need the fastest SR-22 filing in an urban Texas county (Harris, Dallas, Tarrant, Bexar, Travis, El Paso), if you're already enrolled in a DWI education program and want the completion discount applied immediately, or if you're buying a non-owner policy now but plan to own a vehicle within the next 18 months. Dairyland's mid-term conversion policy preserves your SR-22 progress and avoids restarting the 2-year clock.
Choose The General if you need a lower down payment to bind the policy today, if you're in a rural county where filing speed differences are negligible, or if you know you will not own a vehicle during the entire SR-22 period. The General's flat pricing model also produces slightly lower premiums for drivers with multiple violations — DWI plus reckless driving, or DWI plus uninsured citation — because Dairyland compounds risk multipliers for stacked violations.
Both carriers accept drivers with suspended licenses, both file SR-22 electronically through TexasSure, and both maintain AM Best ratings that meet DPS financial responsibility standards. The filing speed gap and the non-owner conversion policy are the structural differences that matter most for Texas SR-22 filers. Compare quotes from both carriers using identical coverage limits, verify the down payment requirement with each, and confirm the filing timeline your county typically sees before binding coverage.